Apple is pushing back against a proposed Canadian law that would give authorities new powers to require technology companies to help access user data.
Bill C-22 would allow the government to order certain companies to modify their services to assist police and intelligence agencies, subject to oversight.
Apple, Google, and Meta are seeking further changes as the legislation moves through the Senate.
The dispute centers on how much assistance governments can demand from technology companies without weakening the privacy protections their customers rely on.
What Canada’s Proposed Law Would Change
Bill C-22 would introduce new requirements for certain technology providers to help authorities access data lawfully.
One provision would allow authorities to require companies to make technical changes that facilitate access to information.
Another would permit orders requiring certain providers to retain connection records for up to six months.
Those records could reveal details about communications, including who is communicating and when, without necessarily exposing message content.
The legislation has also been amended to include safeguards:
- Encryption: Companies could only be required to decrypt information if they applied the encryption and already possess the necessary keys.
- Security protections: Authorities could not force companies to introduce new security vulnerabilities.
- Oversight: Certain technical assistance orders would require approval from Canada’s Intelligence Commissioner.
These restrictions are intended to preserve security protections while allowing authorities to obtain information through lawful processes.
Why Apple Still Has Privacy Concerns
Apple has acknowledged the amendments but maintains that the proposed law could still undermine its ability to protect customer information.
The company’s concern centers on how broadly authorities could require technology providers to change their services, even with restrictions on encryption and security vulnerabilities.
Apple previously warned that such powers could lead to demands for encryption backdoors, creating ways to bypass existing security protections.
The revised legislation explicitly restricts those demands, but Apple argues the safeguards don’t fully resolve its concerns.
The disagreement reflects a broader debate between governments seeking investigative access to digital information and technology companies seeking to preserve strong privacy protections.
What Happens Next?
Bill C-22 has not become law and remains under Senate review.
Representatives from several technology and privacy-focused companies, including Meta, Signal, and Tailscale, were scheduled to testify before a Senate committee.
Lawmakers must now decide whether the existing safeguards are sufficient or whether additional changes are necessary.
For Apple users, the proposed law does not currently change how their devices or encrypted services work. Its eventual impact will depend on the final legislation and how any new powers are implemented.